Thunderbird Cal, Repeating Event, Individual Change Not Sync

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

When I create a repeating event in Thunderbird's calendar, then adjust one occurrence (e.g. time), the change isn't synced to phone.

OTOH, if I adjust the occurence on phone, the change is synced back to Thunderbird.

Any idea?

Thanks in advance.

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Anyone have the same config?

Cheers.

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Same issue reported beforehand:

https://www.fjsoft.at/forum/viewtopic.php?t=35324

Cheers.

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Hi anyone? Very Happy

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Awaiting...

Moderator Anmeldedatum: 19.04.2014 Beiträge: 18094

You probably mean, if you correct a single date of the series (ie an exception) in Thunderbird, this error occurs!?
Thanks for the info, I am forward this issue to FJ

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Yes, you're right

Let's say I create a Mon-Fri recurring schedule of 9am-6pm

Then, if I change one Wednesday occurrence to 10am-7pm in Thunderbird, MPE will not propagate the difference to the phone.

Interestingly, if I make the change on the phone, MPE will propagate back the difference back to Thunderbird.

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Hi there any updates?

Cheers.

Moderator Anmeldedatum: 19.04.2014 Beiträge: 18094

No, not yet.
I have forwarded the problem to FJ without obligation, that's all I can do about it Confused

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Understood and thanks!

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Any chance this is being tackled?

Cheers.

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

Hi anyone? 😁

Moderator Anmeldedatum: 19.04.2014 Beiträge: 18094

Unfortunately FJ hasn't found time to add the feature yet, sorry?!
Just for information: It works with Outlook

Verfasst am: So Jan 14, 2024 12:49

loyukfai hat Folgendes geschrieben:

Yes, you're right

Let's say I create a Mon-Fri recurring schedule of 9am-6pm

Then, if I change one Wednesday occurrence to 10am-7pm in Thunderbird, MPE will not propagate the difference to the phone.

Interestingly, if I make the change on the phone, MPE will propagate back the difference back to Thunderbird.

Confirmed with Tbird 115.6. Did exactly as above and a phone change gets sync'ed to TBird but a TBird change gets ignored.

To add: as this was just ba test for me I then proceeded delete the repeated event in TBird. I clicked on the events first day and hit <DEL>. Thisd deleted all the repeated events except for the one I'd just edited on the phone and sync'ed back to TBird. Maybe this is what should happen but it could point to where the problem is ...?

Moderator Anmeldedatum: 19.04.2014 Beiträge: 18094

@dvhttn
This is so correct and not an error, the exception of the series is realized in MPE as follows:
- The changed appointment is declared as an exception in the series and is therefore deleted
- An individual appointment will be created for the changed appointment

Verfasst am: So Jan 14, 2024 16:17

icke1954 hat Folgendes geschrieben:

@dvhttn
This is so correct and not an error, the exception of the series is realized in MPE as follows:
- The changed appointment is declared as an exception in the series and is therefore deleted
- An individual appointment will be created for the changed appointment

Ah, thought it might be that but you should never *assume* .... Very Happy

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

icke1954 hat Folgendes geschrieben:

Unfortunately FJ hasn't found time to add the feature yet, sorry?!
Just for information: It works with Outlook

Yeah, it works with Outlook, and also the other way around (phone -> TB), so I'm not sure why it happens... but I'm finally switching from Outlook to Thunderbird so...

dvhttn hat Folgendes geschrieben:

loyukfai hat Folgendes geschrieben:

Yes, you're right

Let's say I create a Mon-Fri recurring schedule of 9am-6pm

Then, if I change one Wednesday occurrence to 10am-7pm in Thunderbird, MPE will not propagate the difference to the phone.

Interestingly, if I make the change on the phone, MPE will propagate back the difference back to Thunderbird.

Confirmed with Tbird 115.6. Did exactly as above and a phone change gets sync'ed to TBird but a TBird change gets ignored.

To add: as this was just ba test for me I then proceeded delete the repeated event in TBird. I clicked on the events first day and hit <DEL>. Thisd deleted all the repeated events except for the one I'd just edited on the phone and sync'ed back to TBird. Maybe this is what should happen but it could point to where the problem is ...?

Thanks for confirming. Yes this is the same way in Outlook too, when you change one event out of a recurrance/repeating/series event, the new one will become "detangled" from the original.

The fact that it works in Outlook, and also phone -> Outlook/TB, seems to me something is off for the TB logic.

Anyhow, shall wait for FJ to fix it.

Cheers.

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

One interesting thing I observed is that, deleting one event out of a series will propagate, but changing the time of individual events won't.

Cheers.

Anmeldedatum: 10.03.2022 Beiträge: 33

I tested again on version 2.2

By creating a daily repeating event for 2 days.

When I tried to change the time of the 2nd date.

The change was propagated to the phone.

However, the 1st event/date was incorrectly changed to be the same as the 2nd date too.

Cheers.

Moderator Anmeldedatum: 19.04.2014 Beiträge: 18094

@loyukfai
I can't reproduce the problem?!
Maybe you didn't change the time for the second appointment but for the series of appointments?
Please install => MPE beta version

Informationen zum Datenschutz auf dieser Website